Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Paul Hardy's avatar

English concertina isn’t diatonic - it’s fully chromatic. Indeed it has buttons for both the enharmonic pairs for G#/Ab, D#Eb etc to aid in non equal-tempered tunings). However adding every flat (or sharp) moves a finger away from the home position, and hence takes mental effort to achieve, which takes focus away from interpreting the music. Many non-keyboard instruments have similar key preference - e.g most woodwind instruments. Maybe you should provide a download link for ABC of the tune as supplied, and another of a minimal sharps/flats version ideally F/C/G/D/A (within a couple of tones of the original). Then see which gets downloaded most? I’m happy taking ABC and manipulating or transposing it - see https://pghardy.net/tunebooks/index.html., which are all generated using ABC.

Expand full comment
Paul Hardy's avatar

I've said this before, and I know you had an exercise of using every possible key, but now you have made a new start, why not transpose tunes to friendlier keys? I play English concertina, and although it is possible to play in 6 flats, it's very awkward, and playing in 1# (Gmaj/Emin) would be far easier and only a semitone away!

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts